Hello Reader,
Just so you know – my paper is fair game to say anything you
want about it. Think the grammar is wrong? Okay! Let me know. Think a joke is
lame. Okay too! Say so if that’s important to you. Like something? I know I'm awesome already, but you can let me know anyway. I won’t get mad no matter how
critical the response is. Enjoy.
So far this semester I've learned about the different styles
of writing and punctuation that are evolving, yet still have no solid set rule.
It doesn't come down to WHOSE [possessive pronouns] is better, THEIRS [possessive
pronouns] or YOURS [possessive pronouns]; rather it is still almost a stylistic
difference until the majority decides to follow one rule over the other. From
what we've discussed in class it seems an apostrophe following an “s” instead
of an added apostrophe “s” is the winner in the VHS/Beta like competition.
However, as of right now there are still occasional publications that let the
added apostrophe “s” such as Katie Holmes’s rather than Katie Holmes’ slide.
This particular apostrophe rule seems to be coming to an end agreeing that
apostrophes will follow the letter “s” rather than adding an additional “s”.
AS A STUDENT OF ENGLISH, I PERSONALLY FOLLOW THE RULE OF
WRITING MY APOSTROPHES FOLLOWING “S” RATHER THAN ADDING AN APOSTROPHE AND “S”; AS
A READER, I STILL SEE THE ADDING OF AN ADDITIONAL “S” IN BIG NAME PUBLICATIONS [Parallel
sentences conjoined by semicolon, with introductory phrases, with comma after
the phrase]. If I remember correctly, my magazine I read articles out of for
the class project was People. My
example of Katie Holmes’s was one of the uses of apostrophes my group found. ITS
[possessive pronouns] editor either missed the mistake or agrees with that
style of use. I feel as though the accepted manner of mode for this punctuation
might be a solid rule in the future, but for now it seems both manners are
currently being accepted as correct. But as with most English rules there can
only be one; such is the way of the highlander.. err English grammar rules.
Outside of grammar rules we've been reading about an
imaginary first grader named Dora. I can’t remember how I first learned to
write. I've always assumed I've just been pro at it. But seriously, when I
think back I can vaguely remember working on my writing. I can probably best
remember assignments I've been assigned the last year or two. Any earlier and
assignments I have worked on are a blur, like a night of too much tequila. The
problem with this is that when I try and compare to the examples I've been
reading, I can’t as easily relate to them if I can’t remember my own
experiences from then clearly. I assume my learning went something like the
examples in the Dora article, but there’s no way to be sure which of the two,
free thought or worksheets, I experienced in school.
Aside from Dora, I've been introduced to many ideas of how
children learn to use punctuation. My opinion is that the children having free
reign over their stories and punctuation within a set track to keep them
learning correct use is a good style of learning. I feel things are more
exciting with a little mystery. Some may disagree saying mystery is annoying,
but when you’re a kid discovering things is fun. From my own experience, taking
tests and working on worksheets is nowhere as beneficial as making your own
mistakes. If someone can learn to effectively correct their own grammar
mistakes they can ever evolve to become a better writer.
The last thing I've learned so far is that class ends at
4:05. It seems that even short of 4 o'clock people are PACKING UP, GETTING UP,
LEAVING [List without and]. I have faith we’ll get this one down some day.
Cheers
I've found it very interesting that even the "rules" that have been made for punctuation have changed. It's interesting to realize that even within my own life time some of these rules have been changing, and I haven't even noticed! I liked what you had to say about punctuation, that it doesn't matter whose is better, and that it's a stylistic difference until we can all agree on a certain way.
ReplyDeleteI said the same thing in my own blog: I just can't seem to really remember learning grammar, spelling, or punctuation. And I don't remember whether I had worksheets or used my own writing. Damn my memory for being horrible!
I think we're all just getting anxious shortly before 4:00. It's hard to sit in a classroom for that long. Personally, I'm a little bit more kinesthetic when it comes to learning, so I find it difficult to just sit for a whole class period. That's why I can generally be found with a pen twirling in my hand, or my heel bouncing off the ground.
Just to be clear: that option on apostrophe use only applies to singular nouns ending in -s, right? Also, I don't remember what PEOPLE's style sheet is regarding this categorical use of apostrophe, but I'm guessing that HOLMES'S is consistent with that publication's style sheet, no?
ReplyDeleteAs for the use of series without AND: remember that connotes endless items, whereas activities within your context(our getting out of class early) are definitely finite :->